Stop Over-Diversifying! Why Your Fund Manager's Portfolio Might Be a Hot Mess (and How to Fix Yours)
New Research Reveals the Shocking Reason Fund Managers Underperform: It's Not Just Fees, It's Portfolio Bloat!
Ever wondered why your fund manager's returns sometimes feel... underwhelming? You're not alone. For years, we've been told the story: high fees, human error, market gremlins – the usual suspects. But what if the real culprit was hiding in plain sight, buried within the very strategy they preach: diversification? Prepare for a financial plot twist! Groundbreaking new research has uncovered a shocking truth about why even the smartest money managers often miss the mark, and it's got everything to do with portfolio bloat. Forget blaming just the fees – the real issue might be that they're simply holding too many stocks! Get ready to rethink everything you thought you knew about diversification because we're diving deep into the surprising world of fund manager underperformance and revealing the 5-7 stock secret that could unlock investment awesomeness.
Is Your Fund Manager a Closet Over-Diversifier? The Shocking Truth About Portfolio Size! (Now with Extra Numbers!)
For ages, we've been scratching our heads about why those Wall Street wizards, with their fancy algorithms and insider lingo, often can't seem to beat the market. We've pointed fingers at fees (ouch, those expense ratios!), human brains short-circuiting under pressure (biases galore!), and maybe just a sprinkle of cosmic misfortune (bad luck happens!). But hold the phone, investment junkies, because a recent study has detonated a data bomb: over-diversification is the real portfolio killer! Yep, turns out they might be too good at spreading the wealth (and the stocks!), inadvertently watering down their own genius.
The Diversification Dilemma: When "More" Becomes a Bore
Diversification, the investment mantra we've all chanted! It's like building a balanced plate – a little protein, some veggies, maybe a sprinkle of carbs, so you don't OD on just, say, marshmallows, right? Solid logic! Except... what if you piled every single food item in the grocery store onto your plate? Suddenly, it's less "nutritious variety" and more "culinary chaos." And guess what? That's kinda the portfolio pizza fund managers are serving up.
For decades, the gospel was: more stocks = less risk = investor bliss. But BAM! Data just smacked us with a statistical sledgehammer: typically, a whopping 85-95% of actively managed funds underperform their benchmark over a 10-year period! Stuffing your portfolio like a Thanksgiving turkey with a zillion different stocks is a surprisingly reliable path to blah returns. We're talking about potentially leaving serious money on the table!
165 Stocks?! The Mind-Boggling Portfolio Size Revelation.
Brace yourselves, folks, because the portfolio size stats are truly mind-blowing. This study, like a financial archaeologist, unearthed portfolio data and discovered that the average fund manager in 2018 was wrestling with a gargantuan 165 different stock holdings! Let that number sink in. One. Hundred. And. Sixty. Five! It's like trying to conduct an orchestra with a kazoo – pure chaos!
Think about it: 165 stocks! It's statistically improbable to have deep conviction in that many companies. It's more like a frantic grab bag of everything vaguely investable. And the brutal truth? All that extra "padding" is diluting the real performance drivers. Imagine diluting a potent performance-enhancing serum with 165 gallons of water – you're left with… well, water.
The "Eureka!" Moment: Top Picks are Performance Ninjas, Rest are... Portfolio Passengers
But hold on, there's a plot twist worthy of a financial thriller! The study cracked the code and revealed a hidden talent: fund managers aren't stock-picking duds! In fact, they're surprisingly good! Their top stock selections, the crème de la crème, the investments they'd bet their own bonuses on, absolutely ANNIHILATE the market, delivering a juicy 2.8% to 4.5% annual outperformance! Pow! Mic drop! Data doesn't lie, people!
So, scratch that "fund managers are clueless" narrative! They've got the stock-picking superpowers! The tragedy? Those performance ninjas are getting lost in a mosh pit of portfolio passengers. In fact, in 2021 alone, a staggering 80% of all U.S. active fund managers underperformed the market. And when you zoom in on the big players, 85% of large-cap active fund managers couldn't even keep pace with the S&P 500 index in 2021! Beyond their top, say, top 5 or maybe top 10 conviction picks, the alpha-generating magic fizzles out faster than a cheap firework. It's like having Michael Jordan on your basketball team, but then surrounding him with 164 people who've never touched a basketball before – are you really maximizing his talent?
Less is More: The Power of a Lean, Think 5-7, Statistically Speaking
Alright, time for some actionable intel! Forget the "quantity over quality" investment buffet! This study is basically flashing neon signs saying: CONCENTRATE YOUR CAPITAL! Instead of sprinkling your investments like fairy dust across the entire market, we should be strategic snipers, targeting our highest-conviction targets.
Consider this: instead of owning a microscopic crumb of 165 companies you barely recognize, what if you built a lean, mean portfolio of, let's say, 5 to 7 meticulously researched, high-conviction stocks? Statistically speaking, those winning picks now have room to flex their muscles and drive some serious portfolio gains! It's like trading in that bathtub of weak hot sauce for a concentrated shot of pure, unadulterated flavor – that's how you get noticed! And potentially, that's how you beat the market! And the data backs it up: active fund managers have consistently underperformed a simple global 100 index fund, lagging behind by a massive 47% over the past five years!
Your Portfolio Makeover: Going Hybrid for Maximum ROI
Now, hold your horses, stock-slinging cowboys! Before you liquidate 158 holdings and go all-in on your top 7, let's inject a dose of realism. Diversification isn't the enemy; over-diversification is. Think of it like salt – essential in moderation, disastrous in excess. The winning formula if you’re not sure about your competences? The Hybrid Portfolio Power Play!
Picture your portfolio as a superhero squad, but this time, with clear roles and responsibilities. You've got your rock-solid foundation, the dependable "Broad Market ETF Brigade" – your Iron Mans and Wonder Womans, providing market-wide coverage and stability (allocate, say, 70% of your portfolio here). Then, you unleash your "Concentrated Stock Strike Force" – your Wolverines and Black Widows, the elite specialists, the high-conviction heroes ready to deliver alpha-charged returns (the remaining 30%).
Boom! Hybrid power unleashed! You get the bedrock of broad market diversification plus the rocket fuel of concentrated stock-picking potential. It's like having a balanced diet – you get your nutritious veggies and that delicious, performance-boosting steak! Maximum ROI, maximum deliciousness! And remember, in only 3 out of the last 21 years have the majority of large-cap active managers managed to outperform the S&P 500! The odds are stacked against them – and perhaps against your over-diversified portfolio too!
Quick reminder : Want to dives deep into the strategies I've used to navigate the market and achieve to beat the market. Well, say no more and grab my book "Investing with Eagles." we’ve made it to the top 300 books on portfolio management and investment strategies, check it out on Amazon.
From Portfolio Purgatory to Performance Paradise
So, there you have it, folks! The secret to potentially unlocking market-beating returns isn't about chasing more stocks, it's about curating the best stocks and letting them shine! Fund managers might be unintentionally hamstringing themselves with portfolio bloat, but we, as data-savvy investors, can learn from their numerical missteps.
Time for a portfolio intervention! Are you swimming in a stock soup of 165+ names you can barely pronounce? It's time for a portfolio cleanse! Embrace quality over quantity, unleash the power of focused conviction, and who knows – you might just find your returns are suddenly doing the cha-cha in performance paradise! Data-backed investing, folks – it's the future! Happy (and statistically sound) investing!
Source:
the study :Best Ideas Miguel Antón, Randolph B. Cohen, and Christopher Polk
Statistics on fund manager underperformance from Kernel Wealth: "Majority of Actively Managed Funds Continue to Underperform". Kernel Wealth Blog, 22 June 2022, https://kernelwealth.co.nz/blog/majority-of-actively-managed-funds-continue-to-underperform.
Hungry for More Market-Crushing Insights?
Join our tribe of savvy investors! We're serving up fresh, insightful articles every Tuesday and Thursday to help you navigate the market like a pro.
Tuesdays are for treating yourself! Get a free dose of market wisdom delivered straight to your inbox. We're talking market trends, personal finance tips, and investment strategies to help you level up your game.
Thursdays are for the truly dedicated! Our premium subscribers get the VIP treatment for only :
Exclusive access to my view on earnings releases: Stay ahead of the curve with in-depth analysis and expert commentary.
A peek inside my portfolio: See what moves I'm making and why.
Bonus articles: Dive deeper into the most interesting market happenings.
A free copy of my book: Unlock even more financial knowledge and become a true market master.
Don't let your family eat you! Click here to subscribe and start your journey to financial freedom! Okay, maybe we can't guarantee complete freedom from your family, but we can definitely help you bring home the bacon... or at least the investment returns!
Want to read more?
Disclaimer: The information provided in our analyses and reports is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. We are not financial advisors, and nothing we say or write should be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell any security.
While we strive to provide accurate and insightful information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the information presented.
It is important to note that we may or may not hold positions in the companies we discuss. Any opinions expressed are our own and are subject to change without notice.
Always conduct your own thorough research and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Never invest more than you can afford to lose.